Tequila Old Fashioned: The Perfect Recipe

A true classic never goes out of style—it just gets a modern, and in this case, a delicious Mexican, twist. If you’re a whiskey lover looking to try something new, or a tequila fan ready to experience agave distillates in a whole new way, this tequila old fashioned recipe is for you. It's a smooth, surprising, and sophisticated cocktail that swaps the traditional bourbon or rye for a rich, aged tequila. The result is a drink that feels both familiar and entirely new.

A Brief History of the Old Fashioned (with a Tequila Twist)

The Old Fashioned is, as its name suggests, one of the oldest cocktails ever created. Its simple formula—spirit, sugar, water, and bitters—has been a cornerstone of mixology for over 200 years. While originally made with American whiskey, modern bartenders and home enthusiasts are experimenting with the formula, finding that a well-aged tequila is the perfect substitute. The robust flavors of añejo tequila, with its notes of caramel and oak, stand up beautifully to the sweet and bitter components, creating a delicious agave-based alternative.

A Guide to the Ingredients

The secret to a great cocktail lies in the quality of its ingredients. Each component of this tequila old fashioned cocktail plays a crucial role.

The Tequila

For this recipe, an añejo tequila is the ideal choice. Aged in oak barrels for one to three years, añejo gains a complexity that rivals fine whiskies. Look for notes of vanilla, oak, and butterscotch, which will create a seamless transition from the whiskey-based original. A reposado tequila, aged for a shorter period, is also a great option if you prefer a brighter, more agave-forward flavor.

The Bitters

This is where the magic happens, and our secret weapon truly shines. While most recipes call for Angostura bitters, the rich, subtle complexity of El Guapo™ Spiced Cocoa Bitters is a game-changer. These bitters bring warm notes of Mexican chocolate, cinnamon, and a hint of chile, creating a depth of flavor that complements the aged tequila perfectly. It’s an easy way to elevate your drink from good to truly unforgettable.

The Sweetener

Agave syrup is the obvious and best choice here. As a natural product of the agave plant, it shares a DNA with tequila, making it a perfect partner. Its clean, subtle sweetness allows the other flavors to shine without overpowering them. If you don't have agave syrup, a simple syrup (1:1 sugar to water) can work in a pinch.

The Ultimate Tequila Old Fashioned Recipe

This recipe is simple, elegant, and designed to impress.

Makes one cocktail

• 2 oz Añejo Tequila
• .25 oz Agave Syrup
• 4 dashes El Guapo™ Spiced Cocoa Bitters
• Orange peel & blowtorch, for garnish
• Large ice cube

Instructions:

1. Add the añejo tequila, agave syrup, and El Guapo™ Spiced Cocoa Bitters to a mixing glass.
2. Fill the mixing glass with fresh ice.
3. Stir the mixture for 30 seconds, or until it is well-chilled and properly diluted. You'll know it's ready when the outside of the mixing glass feels frosty.
4. Place a large ice cube in a rocks glass. Strain the cocktail from the mixing glass into the rocks glass.
5. Hold the orange peel over the glass, skin-side down, and torch it lightly with a blowtorch. This will warm the oils and release a beautiful aroma.
6. Express the oils by pinching the peel, then rub it around the rim of the glass. Drop the peel into the cocktail and serve immediately.

Pro Tips for Making the Perfect Cocktail

• Use Large Ice: A single large ice cube melts more slowly than smaller cubes, ensuring your drink stays cold without getting watered down too quickly.
• Don't Over-stir: Stir until chilled, but not so long that the drink becomes watery.
• Garnish Is Key: The torched orange peel isn't just for show. The oils and aroma are a key part of the drinking experience, complementing the tequila and bitters beautifully.

Tequila Old Fashioned Variations

Ready to mix things up? Try one of these variations:

• Smoky Tequila Old Fashioned: Add .25 oz of mezcal to the recipe for a subtle, smoky flavor.
• Spicy Tequila Old Fashioned: Muddle a small slice of jalapeño in the mixing glass before adding the other ingredients.
• Oaxacan Old Fashioned: This popular variation adds a smoky, complex layer by combining equal parts reposado tequila and mezcal.

Looking for more cocktail inspiration? Explore our complete collection of recipes and discover your next favorite drink. Have a question? Contact us for assistance, or visit El Guapo's homepage to explore everything we offer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the best tequila for a tequila old fashioned? 

A: An añejo tequila is typically the best choice due to its smooth, aged flavor profile. Reposado is also an excellent option if you prefer a brighter, more agave-forward taste.

Q: What's the difference between a tequila old fashioned and an Oaxacan old fashioned? 

A: A tequila old fashioned is made exclusively with aged tequila, while an Oaxacan old fashioned combines equal parts aged tequila and mezcal, which adds a distinct smoky flavor.

Q: Can I use simple syrup instead of agave syrup? 

A: Yes, you can. While agave syrup is the most natural fit, simple syrup works well and is a common substitute in many cocktail recipes.